Vitality Watch

Dossier pubmed observational 18-oct-2026
Human cohort, case-control, or epidemiological association

Comparative evaluation of time-to-event analysis methods for mobility limitation in older adults: A multi-cohort benchmarking study.

Key claim: Oblique random survival forests and penalized regression offer the best trade-off between predictive discrimination, calibration, and computational efficiency for forecasting incident mobility limitation in older adults.

Abstract

Time-to-event models are central to aging research, quantifying both whether and when an event occurs. However, guidance on selecting among traditional statistical and machine learning (ML) methods for prediction modeling remains limited, particularly for epidemiologic aging cohorts with wide assessment intervals. Mobility limitation, as a clinically important aging outcome with such complexities, provides a relevant test case for methodological benchmarking. We conducted a systematic benchmark comparison of 14 statistical and ML time-to-event methods using harmonized data from four longitudinal U.S. aging cohorts (N = 14,821). The outcome was time to incident mobility limitation, defined by self-reported walking difficulty or gait speed < 0.8 m/s. Models were evaluated using 4-fold cross-validation repeated 100 times within cohorts. Performance metrics captured complementary dimensions of predictive quality: discrimination (C-index), accuracy and calibration (Brier score, integrated log loss, calibration index), and computational efficiency (model training time). Prespecified decision rules synthesize results across metrics to identify preferable methods. Across pooled analyses, multiple methods demonstrated comparable discrimination, including penalized Cox models, tree-based ensembles, and boosting approaches. Oblique random survival forest achieved the most favorable overall trade-off, combining high discrimination (C-index 0.673), good calibration (Brier score 0.147), and moderate training time (9.2 min). When computational efficiency was prioritized, penalized regression methods may be preferable, with good discrimination and Brier score. These findings support random forest and penalized regression as strong defaults for time-to-event prediction modeling in gerontologic research and highlight the importance of joint evaluation of discrimination, calibration, and feasibility.

Why this matters

Oblique random survival forests and penalized regression offer the best trade-off between predictive discrimination, calibration, and computational efficiency for forecasting incident mobility limitation in older adults.

Source

Link

Briefing card

Comparative evaluation of time-to-event analysis methods for mobility limitation in older adults: A multi-cohort benchmarking study.
Stage: observational · pubmed · 18-oct-2026

Oblique random survival forests and penalized regression offer the best trade-off between predictive discrimination, calibration, and computational efficiency for forecasting incident mobility limitation in older adults.

Cross-references (0)

None recorded — doctrine links and citations appear here as scans and citation sweeps find them.

External: doi:10.1016/j.exger.2026.113363

build build 880 · 2bcef25 · 2026-11-18