Comparative effects of 12-week resistance training on unstable and stable surfaces on muscle stiffness, muscle co-activation, and balance in older patients with knee osteoarthritis.
Key claim: In older adults with knee osteoarthritis, 12 weeks of resistance training on unstable surfaces improved balance, reduced muscle stiffness, and lowered quadriceps–hamstring co-activation more than the same training on stable surfaces, while both reduced pain.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: This randomized trial compared the effects of unstable resistance training (URT), involving resistance exercises on unstable surfaces, and stable resistance training (SRT), performed on stable surfaces, on muscle stiffness, co-activation, and balance in older adults with knee osteoarthritis (KOA). We hypothesized that URT would yield greater improvements by enhancing neuromuscular adaptability. METHODS: Fifty patients with KOA were randomly assigned to the URT group (n = 25) or the SRT group (n = 25). After attrition, 46 participants (URT: n = 23; SRT: n = 23) completed the intervention and were included in the final analysis. Both groups completed a 12-week supervised lower-limb resistance training program (3 sessions/week) consisting of 10 exercises performed under either unstable or stable support conditions. RESULTS: After 12 weeks of intervention, both groups showed significant reductions in pain intensity (p < 0.001). However, compared with the SRT group, the URT group demonstrated significantly greater reductions in quadriceps stiffness (p < 0.05), selected hamstring stiffness outcomes (p < 0.05), and quadriceps-hamstring co-activation (p < 0.001), alongside superior improvements in both dynamic balance and static balance (all p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: While both training modalities are effective for pain relief, URT elicited greater improvements in balance-related performance and neuromuscular-mechanical outcomes than SRT in older adults with KOA. These findings suggest that incorporating unstable support conditions into resistance training may provide additional rehabilitation benefits for this population.
Why this matters
Resistance training is the strongest-evidenced lever against sarcopenia, but how the load is delivered — stable bench/machine vs unstable-surface — shapes which systems adapt. This small KOA trial sits inside a growing comparative-modality literature (perturbation, agility, sensory) suggesting that for balance and neuromuscular outcomes the surface condition matters, not just the load, even when pain reduction is similar across arms.