Are the days gone when age mattered? A national-level comparison of frailty versus age in predicting postoperative outcomes.
Key claim: In adults ≥50 undergoing general surgery, Modified Frailty Index score—not chronological age—significantly predicted 30-day mortality across low-, intermediate-, and high-risk procedures, with only weak agreement between age and frailty.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: This study aimed to evaluate the relationship between age, frailty, and surgical outcomes in older adult populations undergoing low-, intermediate-, and high-risk general surgical operations. METHODS: This is a retrospective study of the 2022 National Surgical Quality Improvement Program. Adult patients (≥50 years) undergoing general surgery procedures were stratified by surgical risk (low, intermediate, and high). Patients were stratified based on decades of age and Modified Frailty Index score. The primary outcome was 30-day mortality, and secondary outcomes were 30-day readmission and major complications. RESULTS: A total of 94,882 patients were identified, of which 63.4% underwent low-risk, 27% underwent intermediate-risk, and 9.6% underwent high-risk general surgeries. Cohen’s kappa coefficient was 0.089, indicating poor agreement between frailty score and age category. On univariate and multivariable regression analysis, increasing frailty score was significantly associated with increased rates and adjusted odds of 30-day mortality, whereas age was not identified as a risk factor for this outcome. Subanalysis of outcomes identified frailty, but not age, as a predictor of 30-day mortality among patients who underwent low (adjusted odds ratio, 2.279; P < .001), intermediate (adjusted odds ratio, 1.465; P < .001), and high (adjusted odds ratio, 1.245; P < .03) risk surgeries. CONCLUSION: Increasing frailty score, not age, was found to be significantly associated with mortality of older adults. Counterintuitively, as procedural risk decreased, the predictive strength of frailty on outcomes became more pronounced. The weak correlation between age and frailty further suggests that chronological age may no longer hold meaningful value in guiding surgical decisions for both minor and major general surgical operations.
Why this matters
Surgical risk stratification has been the most clinically consequential testing ground for ‘biological vs chronological age’ claims, and this large NSQIP analysis extends the pattern across surgical risk strata rather than a single procedure. The weak agreement between age and frailty scores operationalizes a core premise of this area — that aging-measurement tools carry information chronological age does not — in a setting where the outcome (30-day mortality) is hard and adjudicated.