Vitality Watch

Dossier pubmed observational 01-oct-2026
Human cohort, case-control, or epidemiological association

Objective Physical Performance Predicts 10-Year Fracture Risk Without Densitometry in Older Men and Women: Development and Head-to-Head Comparison with FRAX in MrOS and SOF.

Key claim: A five-variable model of age, BMI, grip strength, gait speed and chair-stand rate predicts 10-year major osteoporotic fracture risk at least as well as FRAX without BMD in older men, without densitometry, labs or fracture history.

Abstract

FRAX estimates 10-year fracture probability from clinical risk factors and, for best performance, DXA-derived bone mineral density (BMD), limiting its use where densitometry is unavailable. We tested whether a five-variable, laboratory- and imaging-free model (age, body-mass index, grip strength, gait speed and chair-stand rate; M5) predicts incident fracture and how it compares with FRAX. In community-dwelling older men (Osteoporotic Fractures in Men Study, n = 5994; 73.7 years) and women (Study of Osteoporotic Fractures, n = 9704; 71.6 years) with baseline physical-performance measures and adjudicated incident major osteoporotic fracture (848 and 2522 events), M5 was developed by five-fold cross-validation; we assessed time-dependent AUC at 5, 10 and 15 years, calibration and decision-curve net benefit. Comparators were FRAX in men and a conservative FRAX-surrogate model (in-cohort clinical risk factors) in women, since individually linked, licensed FRAX scores were not available for SOF. In men, M5 discriminated fracture better than FRAX without BMD (10-year ΔAUC + 0.052, 95% CI + 0.023 to + 0.080) and did not differ significantly from FRAX with BMD (+ 0.029, - 0.005 to + 0.063) in this cross-validated, in-cohort comparison; adding BMD to M5 gave the highest discrimination. In women, M5 did not differ significantly from the FRAX-surrogate comparator (- 0.008, - 0.018 to + 0.002), and BMD-based models performed best. M5 was well calibrated (calibration slope 0.97-0.98) and gave higher (men) or equivalent (women) net benefit. Death was a major competing event (72.7% of men, 61.4% of women) but changed 10-year incidence by ~ 1 percentage point. A five-variable, laboratory- and imaging-free model incorporating physical performance stratifies 10-year fracture risk at least as well as FRAX without BMD in men, without requiring imaging, laboratory tests or fracture history. Because M5 was developed within these cohorts whereas FRAX is an external, fixed algorithm, part of this margin reflects development asymmetry; the findings are promising but require external validation before clinical use, and do not replace measured BMD.

Why this matters

Fracture-risk tools in widespread clinical use (FRAX) lean on DXA, labs and self-reported history; a model matching FRAX-without-BMD using only age, BMI and three bedside performance tests would move fracture prediction into settings without densitometry and into the same measurement layer already used for frailty and functional aging. The development remains in-cohort in MrOS and SOF and awaits external validation, so this is a comparative-discrimination claim about an aging measurement tool, not evidence that acting on M5 scores changes fracture outcomes.

Source

Link

Briefing card

Objective Physical Performance Predicts 10-Year Fracture Risk Without Densitometry in Older Men and Women: Development and Head-to-Head Comparison with FRAX in MrOS and SOF.
Stage: observational · pubmed · 01-oct-2026

If you already have grip strength, gait speed, and chair-stand rate measured, those five variables (plus age and BMI) estimate your 10-year major osteoporotic fracture risk about as well as FRAX run without a bone-density scan — in the development cohort, not yet externally validated.

A five-variable model of age, BMI, grip strength, gait speed and chair-stand rate predicts 10-year major osteoporotic fracture risk at least as well as FRAX without BMD in older men, without densitometry, labs or fracture history.

Cross-references (0)

None recorded — doctrine links and citations appear here as scans and citation sweeps find them.

External: doi:10.1007/s00223-026-01618-3

build build 880 · 2bcef25 · 2026-11-18