Vitality Watch

Dossier pubmed meta analysis 19-aug-2026
Systematic review or meta-analysis of multiple human studies

Plant-versus animal-derived protein and nutritional, cardiometabolic, and inflammatory outcomes in middle-aged and older adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.

Key claim: A meta-analysis of 29 RCTs in adults aged ≥50 years found plant- and animal-derived protein interventions produced generally similar effects on body composition, strength, cardiometabolic, and inflammatory outcomes, with only a marginal total-cholesterol benefit favoring plant protein.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Interest in plant-derived proteins and cardiometabolic health is growing, yet evidence directly comparing plant- and animal-derived protein intake in middle-aged and older adults remains inconsistent. AIMS: This systematic review and meta-analysis evaluated the effects of plant-versus animal-derived protein interventions on nutritional status, cardiometabolic health, and inflammatory outcomes in adults aged ≥50 years. METHODS: PubMed, Scopus, Google Scholar, and ClinicalTrials.gov were searched for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) published between January 2000 and August 2025. Eligible studies included adults aged ≥50 years, intervention durations of >1 month, and direct comparisons between plant- and animal-derived protein interventions. Random-effects meta-analyses were performed, and risk of bias was assessed using the Cochrane Risk of Bias 2 tool. Exploratory subgroup analyses were conducted according to daily plant- and animal-protein intake, using 27 g/day as the data-derived median for both protein sources; intervention duration, using 12 weeks as the data-derived median; sex composition; and the presence or absence of an exercise intervention. RESULTS: Twenty-nine RCTs involving 2363 participants were included; 61.3% of participants were female, with 1174 assigned to animal-protein group and 1189 to plant-protein group. Most trials compared soy-based protein interventions with dairy-derived proteins; 25 of the 29 (86%) included RCTs used soy as the plant-protein source, and 23 of 29 (79%) evaluated purified protein isolates or isolate-based products rather than whole foods. Seven trials included an exercise intervention. Pooled analyses showed no significant differences between plant- and animal-protein interventions on body composition, including lean mass and handgrip strength, and on most blood indices. A marginal reduction in total cholesterol (T-CHOL) favored plant protein with substantial between-study heterogeneity (Hedges’ g = -0.31, 95% CI: -0.62 to -0.00; I= 86.20%). Exploratory analyses suggested that plant protein favored T-CHOL among comparisons with plant-protein intake <27 g/day, animal-protein intake <27 g/day, or no exercise intervention. Conversely, diastolic blood pressure (DBP) favored animal protein among comparisons with animal-protein intake <27 g/day. Findings were accompanied by increased heterogeneity. CONCLUSIONS: Plant- and animal-derived protein interventions produced generally similar effects on nutritional, cardiometabolic, and inflammatory outcomes in adults aged ≥50 years. However, the predominance of soy-based isolates and dairy-derived comparators, together with substantial between-study heterogeneity, limits the certainty and generalizability of the findings. The results should be interpreted as evidence from controlled protein-source interventions rather than as evidence of equivalence between whole-food plant and animal protein substitutions. Further RCTs evaluating diverse whole-protein foods within protein-adequate, isocaloric, and nutritionally well-characterized dietary patterns are warranted. PROSPERO REGISTRATION ID: CRD420261304953.

Why this matters

Plant-versus-animal protein is one of the most contested levers in popular aging nutrition, with influencer narratives on both sides claiming decisive metabolic or longevity advantages. This meta-analysis of 29 RCTs in the ≥50 population finds the two sources largely interchangeable for the body-composition, strength, and cardiometabolic surrogates measured, so the practical question for older adults shifts back toward total protein adequacy rather than source. The signal is bounded by soy dominating the plant arms and by the absence of hard-outcome data.

Source

Link

Briefing card

Plant-versus animal-derived protein and nutritional, cardiometabolic, and inflammatory outcomes in middle-aged and older adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.
Stage: meta analysis · pubmed · 19-aug-2026

If you are over 50 and choosing between plant- and animal-based protein for muscle, cardiometabolic, or inflammatory reasons, pooled trial data show broadly similar short-term effects on those markers, with a small total-cholesterol edge for plant protein.

A meta-analysis of 29 RCTs in adults aged ≥50 years found plant- and animal-derived protein interventions produced generally similar effects on body composition, strength, cardiometabolic, and inflammatory outcomes, with only a marginal total-cholesterol benefit favoring plant protein.

Cross-references (0)

None recorded — doctrine links and citations appear here as scans and citation sweeps find them.

External: doi:10.1016/j.clnesp.2026.105027

build build 880 · 2bcef25 · 2026-11-18